| Winner | Runner-Up |
| Winter 2004 | Wacky Funsters | UCU Chalkers |
| Summer 2005 | Royal Jokers | Echo Bar Happy Days |
| Winter 2005 | UCU Breakers | Pendos Huslters |
| Summer 2006 | Earls of Erindale | Lords of Lanyon |
| Winter 2006 | UCU Strikers | Earls of Erindale |
| Summer 2007 | Jamison Jammers | O’Shea’s ToSheahs |
| Winter 2007 | Kambah Inn Kambastards | Coolabar Dubber Ruckies |
| Summer 2008 | The Venue Kickers | Coolabar Dubber Ruckies |
| Winter 2008 | Waniassa Rail Runners | Maram Motley Cues |
| Summer 2009 | Maram Motley Cues | Ojo’s Gremlins |
| Winter 2009 | Maram Concords | Earls of Erindale |
| Summer 2010 | Southern Cross Gringos | Darcy’s Defenestrators |
| Winter 2010 | Maram Motley Cues | Ojo’s Hot Pockets |
| Summer 2011 | Uni Bombers | Buffalo Bistro Buffalos |
| Winter 2011 | Maram Balls Deep All Stars | Felt Rippers |
| Summer 2012 | Uni Pub Motley Cues | Civic Pub Felt Rippers |
| Winter 2012 | Mooseheads Rangers | Kambah Inn Neil & Bob |
| Summer 2013 | Uni Pub UniBombers | Civic Pub Felt Rippers |
| Winter 2013 | Fyshwick Tavern Schlutz | Kambah Inn Balls Deep All Stars |
| Summer 2014 | Burns Club Nevilles | Mooseheads Rangers |
| Winter 2014 | Kambah Inn Neil & Bob | Dickson Tradies Silver Eagles |
| Summer 2015 | Dickson Tradies Eagles | Basement WHIPS |
| Winter 2015 | Buffalo Bistro Chickenbones | Rail Runners |
| Summer 2016 | Calwell Tavern Just the Tip | Shooters |
| Winter 2016 | Capital Golf Club Shooters | Labor Club Flying Hellfish |
| Summer 2017 | The Basement Jacks | Labor Club Flying Hellfish |
| Winter 2017 | Buffalo Bistro Chickenbones | Buffalo Bistro Buffalos |
| Summer 2018 | The Basement Baseballs | Labor Club Demolition |
| Winter 2018 | Labor Club Demolition | Qbn Roos Club Plastered Pocket Roos |
| Summer 2019 | Qbn Roos Club Plastered Pocket Roos | PJ O’Reilly’s Drop Bears |
| Winter 2019 | Buffalo Bistro Chickenbones | PJ O’Reilly’s Drop Bears |
